I wish people would actually go on a goldtrowel course before they judge it. I went on a 1 week goldtrowel course because I wasnt willing to pay a plasterer £700 to render my outhouse which I built. Why you ask? ...because I paid for an '27year experienced plasterer' to patch my wall, and he left if a pile of s**t! I wouldn't judge all plasterers on his performance though, the same way you can't judge all course providers or students that do the courses.
Ask yourself why these courses exist. Virtually no one wants to give people a chance, and when they do, the lad just gets stuck on tea duties, mixing, with virtually no time on the tools because they don't want to lose a good labourer. ...Nothing wrong with that if you have 3-5 years to waste working for pennies before you get to practice the trade. Sorry to say it, but any monkey can mix, and monkey can clean up, and anyone can make tea. What the course does is get you straight on the tools from day one. The guys that run the course are all very experienced, quick, and thorough spreads. Instead of them working and giving you a few pointers as they go, they are teaching you all day and you are practicing on rough, wonky s**t walls all day for 5 days a week. If you don't think that 6 weeks of solid tuition, and practise will give you a good start then you are deluded. As for the theory, that is covered in manuals and dvds before the course, so before you even start you have a good insight into the proceedures and techniques. All thats needed is loads of practice- which you get.
1 square metre???? ..b*ll***s...you get your own rooms, your own spot board and a set of tools and away you go. The rooms gradually get bigger, then some ******* (instructor) comes along an smashes a hole or two in it for you to make good. Have a look at the sylabus for the big courses- its just a small portion of what you end up doing. I know there are some bad courses out there, but goldtrowel is not one of them. Check it out before you judge them.
When I went to the course I saw what the people on the city and guilds were capable of- it was impressive. Would I pay for the work they did? Absolutly. Do I think they need practice to get quicker? Yes. Remember that most customers want a good job, not a quick one. I should know...I was one.
I've skimmed many rooms in my house to a good standard, I've built an outhouse in my garden from scratch, and I feel ready to work for other people. But I am still going to do my C&G because I think that I should be qualified by a body of autority, not a spread that has his own agenda.