Prefer skimming artex than...

lurpak said:
b*ll***s. By that logic why is the existing fine? How would a fex extra mm make any difference? Don’t say the extra weight as it’s distributed ovef the entire area.

Only overboard if ceiling is failing
Click to expand...
Artex isn't solid thickness all over , so the thicker parts only cover a small area's so is less prone to cracking
Another point is your relying on someone else's work , it should be checked that its not
already a cover on old skim , more bonding issues , dirty boards , dry PVA etc
 
Havagojo said:
Artex isn't solid thickness all over , so the thicker parts only cover a small area's so is less prone to cracking
Another point is your relying on someone else's work , it should be checked that its not
already a cover on old skim , more bonding issues , dirty boards , dry PVA etc
Click to expand...

17/18 years dread to think how much artex I’ve covered i do it week in week out in all different properties. Never had one fail. I know when to overboard and it’s rare.

People overboard artex just for the fun of it. It’s crazy.
 
I still wear these...
36280
For PE.
 
lurpak said:
17/18 years dread to think how much artex I’ve covered i do it week in week out in all different properties. Never had one fail. I know when to overboard and it’s rare.

People overboard artex just for the fun of it. It’s crazy.
Click to expand...
Just making a point , you think its not valid but if you were asked to put 1/2" solid on a ceiling would you do it
 
Havagojo said:
Just making a point , you think its not valid but if you were asked to put 1/2" solid on a ceiling would you do it
Click to expand...

It isn’t a point if it’s not true tho it’s an opinion. It’s all down to the plasterers knowledge and skills. @John j posted a picture of skim coming off a non artex ceiling then other day. Non artex and probably 2mm skim and came down in sheets.

Never needed to put half inch on a lid. What sort of artex you skimming lol.
 
lurpak said:
It isn’t a point if it’s not true tho it’s an opinion. It’s all down to the plasterers knowledge and skills. @John j posted a picture of skim coming off a non artex ceiling then other day. Non artex and probably 2mm skim and came down in sheets.

Never needed to put half inch on a lid. What sort of artex you skimming lol.
Click to expand...
My point is you wouldn't want to put thick plaster onto a ceiling which is flexible and rely on previous plastering , its not meant for you as you will carry on regardless lol , no offence , its for others to consider when deciding how to proceed , been flattening artex for 35y and I may be Ott but doubt even JJ would put solid 10mm on a ceiling , as I pointed out , depends on foot traffic above and span / flex of ceiling
 
Havagojo said:
My point is you wouldn't want to put thick plaster onto a ceiling which is flexible and rely on previous plastering , its not meant for you as you will carry on regardless lol , no offence , its for others to consider when deciding how to proceed , been flattening artex for 35y and I may be Ott but doubt even JJ would put solid 10mm on a ceiling , as I pointed out , depends on foot traffic above and span / flex of ceiling
Click to expand...
Who.s putting ten mm . I.m only on about filling pattern
 
Havagojo said:
My point is you wouldn't want to put thick plaster onto a ceiling which is flexible and rely on previous plastering , its not meant for you as you will carry on regardless lol , no offence , its for others to consider when deciding how to proceed , been flattening artex for 35y and I may be Ott but doubt even JJ would put solid 10mm on a ceiling , as I pointed out , depends on foot traffic above and span / flex of ceiling
Click to expand...

So your concern is the adhesion to the artex? Or the extra weight on joists?
 
lurpak said:
Plaster doesn’t flex at any thickness
Click to expand...
So that's the point I was making ,
Not necessarily to you but others who " do a bit of artex back to flat "
Consideration of a few things rather than capability
 
Havagojo said:
So that's the point I was making ,
Not necessarily to you but others who " do a bit of artex back to flat "
Consideration of a few things rather than capability
Click to expand...

Sounded to me like you was insinuating that a thinner coat of plaster would flex and not crack, but a thicker coat wouldn’t.

Anywho who cares. You’re right in that skimming artex isn’t always straight forward and can end in failure if the spread isnt knowledgable on it/site monkey doing a Saturday job lol
 
Ironically I'm doing mine Saturday!

lurpak said:
Sounded to me like you was insinuating that a thinner coat of plaster would flex and not crack, but a thicker coat wouldn’t.

Anywho who cares. You’re right in that skimming artex isn’t always straight forward and can end in failure if the spread isnt knowledgable on it/site monkey doing a Saturday job lol
Click to expand...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page

Back
Top