Thistle Plasters Q&A

zombie said:
They dont care mate, not even worth typing your greivence!
Click to expand...
Thistle Plasters Q&A
 
Can i add . Great choice of time . From a part timers point of view its very quiet on here bout 5/6 oclock
....

.why I wonder
Oh yeah
Full timers have just got in and sat having there tea n spending time with kids
How about 8/9 pm when everyones been in bath and chilled or a bit
 
paulf said:
That's bad patter mate, that shouldn't be right.
Click to expand...
spent an hour on phone this week to bg first then formula the casting plaster makers its 80 bags or f/all internet sales want £30 per bag delivery plus £14 a bag so think I will call it a day cant be f**k*d anymore just turned 2 jobs down this week just going to do a few patching jobs kitchens etc THANKS ST GOBAIN
 
zombie said:
Ive got an offe @bg


Tbf i honestly wouldnt have even heard of pure if not for @Vincey!

Though im sure hes on the payroll!
Click to expand...
Seriously mate I thought after using uni I want to try them all to find which one I thought was the best , tbf I think all the skim plaster they do have different advantages, but the top two I liked to trowel up on plasterboard were pure and thistle spray
But out of the two I’d go pure if I had to choice just one
 
lurpak said:
I still think they're adjusting the formula to better suit plastic trowels to "stay with the times"

Cause the gear hates a worn in ss
Click to expand...
I use to just use my tyzack ss start to finish no problems. Now I only coat with it and use my old mt carbon to trowel up. The carbon is much lighter though, probably puts less stress on the surface. You know what I feel like I shouldn't have to post this shite.
 
Vincey said:
Seriously mate I thought after using uni I want to try them all to find which one I thought was the best , tbf I think all the skim plaster they do have different advantages, but the top two I liked to trowel up on plasterboard were pure and thistle spray
But out of the two I’d go pure if I had to choice just one
Click to expand...
Unless they've changed the Spray Finish since release I can't understand how you'd think that is a decent bit of gear to use? Even BG advised the need for a plasi trowel to stop it tearing in the latter stages of trowelling up.
 
@BritishGypsum
Your Multifinish is very, very poor. It has been poor for so long that many guys have either never used decent plaster or have just forgotten what it was like.
It is my honest opinion that the problems really started with you pushing a 'one fits all' plaster, namely Multifinish.
When I started we had Sirapite, Thistle Board Finish and Carlite Finish, three quite different plasters for different substrates.
Every plasterer knew that Carlite was super fine to get over the high suction of Browning, was horrible and slimey to mix and would always show streaks wherever water touched it during trowelling. No one would have wanted to use it on plasterboard or S&C.
Thistle Board Finish was a much coarser plaster. Easier to mix and troweled up nicely on plasterboard or low suction S&C. But you definitely wouldn't have wanted to use it on high suction backgrounds.
So where are we at with Multifinish?
IMO it is designed primarily to be suitable for getting over the higher suction of Hardwall, which in turn makes it slimey, snotty and greasy when used on plasterboard.
Board Finish
Bizarrely this is now a finer plaster than it was years ago, God knows why? This again can cause it to be greasy to use.
So you now make more different types of finish plaster than ever before, but refuse to make the core products truly suitable for use, dedicated plasters for different backgrounds, just like years ago. Are you familiar with the saying 'if it isn't broken don't try to fix it'? Well this is exactly what you're guilty of.

And all the spreads lived miserably ever after.

The end.
 
What do some of the older guys who work at BG say about this issue .? Surly there are some of there demo team old enough to remember what finish was like years ago and see all the points being made by many of the experienced and long serving spreads on here.
 
beader said:
What do some of the older guys who work at BG say about this issue .? Surly there are some of there demo team old enough to remember what finish was like years ago and see all the points being made by many of the experienced and long serving spreads on here.
Click to expand...

They say “sometimes its a different gypsym and can be a bit ‘clayey’ “
 
beader said:
What do some of the older guys who work at BG say about this issue .? Surly there are some of there demo team old enough to remember what finish was like years ago and see all the points being made by many of the experienced and long serving spreads on here.
Click to expand...
I think they say "I'm getting very close to getting my full pension and I buggered if I'm going to rock the boat, f**k the spreads".
 
@malc im guessing you have always used MT start to finish, so why the super flex at the end? Is it the change you’ve seen in plaster over the years or just to make final pass easier?
 
Not skimmed for a while but skimmed today, gear was rank really streaky and greasy, to much elbow needed cross ways to make it right
 
Lodan said:
Aye...no water it tears, water and it streaks, only option is to leave but not ready to be left...just have to battle on
Click to expand...

Left set yesterday was completely turned went to cross is and pulled fat up n teared . Just disgusting shite
 
Chap I work with anytime I skim the conversation is all about "how's the gear today" doesn't seem right that it's that changeable from bag to bag
 
I
lurpak said:
Left set yesterday was completely turned went to cross is and pulled fat up n teared . Just disgusting shite
Click to expand...
I had that today , still tearing on last trowel when it was hard
 
jamesthefirst said:
@malc im guessing you have always used MT start to finish, so why the super flex at the end? Is it the change you’ve seen in plaster over the years or just to make final pass easier?
Click to expand...

i have only used Marshalltown trowel since the late 70s when i had to go to London to purchase my first Marshalltown.
i purchased the retina flex, it gave a good finish with not so much effort.
Multi finish is very fine compared to Sirapite which was a more open corse finish, more like the required eggshell finish.
 
Lodan said:
Aye...no water it tears, water and it streaks, only option is to leave but not ready to be left...just have to battle on
Click to expand...
Exactly with board other day I had a right s**t background it was masonary painted wtf so day b4 I used some thistle bond it first coat fantastic let it pull in 2nds on pulled in fast same scenario n like u left it in the end light trowel with Nela flex job done but what a f**k about
 
malc said:
i have only used Marshalltown trowel since the late 70s when i had to go to London to purchase my first Marshalltown.
i purchased the retina flex, it gave a good finish with not so much effort.
Multi finish is very fine compared to Sirapite which was a more open corse finish, more like the required eggshell finish.
Click to expand...
Thank you @malc, so few left to remember the good gear. How easy was it to use the coarser gear?
 
lurpak said:
What seems to be clear, is the ones having issues are having the exact same issues. @Lodan described it well
Click to expand...
It's not that you can't finish it, it's just really hard work and occasionally when bags are good it's effortless...that makes it more annoying that's it's right sometimes ....like bully....here's what you could have won
 
Lodan said:
It's not that you can't finish it, it's just really hard work and occasionally when bags are good it's effortless...that makes it more annoying that's it's right sometimes ....like bully....here's what you could have won
Click to expand...

Couldn't agree more.
 
Lodan said:
It's not that you can't finish it, it's just really hard work and occasionally when bags are good it's effortless...that makes it more annoying that's it's right sometimes ....like bully....here's what you could have won
Click to expand...
See even a non spread has mailed the issues. Well done you bady builder (unqualified).
 
Lodan said:
Good job I'm Not easily offended ...I'd post some pics of my current loft conversion but know there'd be a load of internet warriors getting off on it finding a bead a mil out and getting a little self satisfied erection
Click to expand...

Well, don't put your beads a mil out and you have nothing to fear, do you?
 
Stevieo said:
Well, don't put your beads a mil out and you have nothing to fear, do you?
Click to expand...
I wish someone made told me earlier..just made.a feature wall and the top one 770m and the bottom one was 775m...very ashamed
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page

Back
Top